Contact us
|
Home
|
Login
| Users Online: 167
Feedback
Subscribe
Advertise
Search
Advanced Search
Month wise articles
Figures next to the month indicate the number of articles in that month
2022
March
[
1
]
January
[
10
]
2021
December
[
7
]
November
[
9
]
September
[
8
]
August
[
2
]
July
[
1
]
June
[
4
]
May
[
3
]
April
[
4
]
March
[
7
]
February
[
3
]
January
[
6
]
2020
December
[
2
]
November
[
5
]
October
[
3
]
September
[
2
]
August
[
8
]
July
[
4
]
June
[
2
]
May
[
1
]
April
[
3
]
March
[
3
]
February
[
6
]
January
[
1
]
2019
December
[
6
]
November
[
4
]
September
[
4
]
August
[
3
]
July
[
6
]
June
[
1
]
May
[
2
]
April
[
6
]
March
[
3
]
February
[
4
]
January
[
2
]
2018
December
[
10
]
November
[
4
]
October
[
3
]
September
[
4
]
August
[
1
]
July
[
3
]
June
[
5
]
May
[
4
]
April
[
10
]
March
[
2
]
February
[
4
]
2017
December
[
5
]
November
[
4
]
October
[
3
]
September
[
9
]
July
[
5
]
June
[
2
]
May
[
4
]
April
[
6
]
March
[
6
]
February
[
7
]
2016
December
[
7
]
November
[
5
]
October
[
3
]
September
[
7
]
August
[
1
]
July
[
7
]
May
[
8
]
April
[
7
]
March
[
4
]
February
[
2
]
January
[
5
]
2015
November
[
4
]
October
[
5
]
September
[
5
]
August
[
4
]
July
[
3
]
June
[
19
]
May
[
5
]
April
[
1
]
March
[
5
]
February
[
9
]
January
[
3
]
2014
November
[
2
]
October
[
5
]
September
[
4
]
August
[
6
]
July
[
8
]
June
[
1
]
May
[
3
]
March
[
8
]
February
[
3
]
January
[
4
]
2013
December
[
5
]
November
[
2
]
October
[
4
]
September
[
4
]
August
[
3
]
July
[
3
]
June
[
5
]
May
[
7
]
March
[
18
]
February
[
1
]
January
[
1
]
2012
December
[
6
]
November
[
1
]
October
[
4
]
September
[
4
]
August
[
7
]
July
[
2
]
June
[
1
]
May
[
2
]
April
[
7
]
March
[
6
]
February
[
7
]
January
[
13
]
2011
December
[
3
]
November
[
1
]
October
[
7
]
August
[
9
]
July
[
3
]
June
[
7
]
May
[
3
]
March
[
6
]
February
[
8
]
January
[
6
]
2010
December
[
4
]
November
[
1
]
October
[
6
]
September
[
1
]
August
[
6
]
July
[
6
]
May
[
5
]
» Articles published in the past year
To view other articles click corresponding year from the navigation links on the left side.
All
|
Book Review
|
Commentary
|
Editorials
|
Original Articles
|
Research Article
|
Review Articles
|
Symposium - Original Articles
|
Symposium - Original Research
|
Technical Note
Export selected to
Endnote
Reference Manager
Procite
Medlars Format
RefWorks Format
BibTex Format
Show all abstracts
Show selected abstracts
Export selected to
Add to my list
Research Article:
Optimal z-axis scanning parameters for gynecologic cytology specimens
Amber D Donnelly, Maheswari S Mukherjee, Elizabeth R Lyden, Julia A Bridge, Subodh M Lele, Najia Wright, Mary F McGaughey, Alicia M Culberson, Adam J Horn, Whitney R Wedel, Stanley J Radio
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:38 (31 December 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.124015
PMID
:24524004
Background:
The use of virtual microscopy (VM) in clinical cytology has been limited due to the inability to focus through three dimensional (3D) cell clusters with a single focal plane (2D images). Limited information exists regarding the optimal scanning parameters for 3D scanning.
Aims:
The purpose of this study was to determine the optimal number of the focal plane levels and the optimal scanning interval to digitize gynecological (GYN) specimens prepared on SurePath
™
glass slides while maintaining a manageable file size.
Subjects and Methods:
The iScanCoreo Au scanner (Ventana, AZ, USA) was used to digitize 192 SurePath
™
glass slides at three focal plane levels at 1 μ interval. The digitized virtual images (VI) were annotated using BioImagene's Image Viewer. Five participants interpreted the VI and recorded the focal plane level at which they felt confident and later interpreted the corresponding glass slide specimens using light microscopy (LM). The participants completed a survey about their experiences. Inter-rater agreement and concordance between the VI and the glass slide specimens were evaluated.
Results:
This study determined an overall high intra-rater diagnostic concordance between glass and VI (89-97%), however, the inter-rater agreement for all cases was higher for LM (94%) compared with VM (82%). Survey results indicate participants found low grade dysplasia and koilocytes easy to diagnose using three focal plane levels, the image enhancement tool was useful and focusing through the cells helped with interpretation; however, the participants found VI with hyperchromatic crowded groups challenging to interpret. Participants reported they prefer using LM over VM. This study supports using three focal plane levels and 1 μ interval to expand the use of VM in GYN cytology.
Conclusion:
Future improvements in technology and appropriate training should make this format a more preferable and practical option in clinical cytology.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (11) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Commentary:
Needs and workflow assessment prior to implementation of a digital pathology infrastructure for the US Air Force Medical Service
Keith J Kaplan
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:37 (31 December 2013)
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Color correction for automatic fibrosis quantification in liver biopsy specimens
Yuri Murakami, Tokiya Abe, Akinori Hashiguchi, Masahiro Yamaguchi, Akira Saito, Michiie Sakamoto
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:36 (31 December 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.124009
PMID
:24524002
Context:
For a precise and objective quantification of liver fibrosis, quantitative evaluations through image analysis have been utilized. However, manual operations are required in most cases for extracting fiber areas because of color variation included in digital pathology images.
Aims:
The purpose of this research is to propose a color correction method for whole slide images (WSIs) of Elastica van Gieson (EVG) stained liver biopsy tissue specimens and to realize automated operation of image analysis for fibrosis quantification.
Materials and Methods:
Our experimental dataset consisted of 38 WSIs of liver biopsy specimens collected from 38 chronic viral hepatitis patients from multiple medical facilities, stained with EVG and scanned at ×20 using a Nano Zoomer 2.0 HT (Hamamatsu Photonics K.K., Hamamatsu, Japan). Color correction was performed by modifying the color distribution of a target WSI so as to fit to the reference, where the color distribution was modeled by a set of two triangle pyramids. Using color corrected WSIs; fibrosis quantification was performed based on tissue classification analysis.
Statistical Analysis Used:
Spearman's rank correlation coefficients were calculated between liver stiffness measured by transient elastography and median area ratio of collagen fibers calculated based on tissue classification results.
Results:
Statistical analysis results showed a significant correlation
r
= 0.61-0.68 even when tissue classifiers were trained by using a subset of WSIs, while the correlation coefficients were reduced to
r
= 0.40-0.50 without color correction.
Conclusions:
Fibrosis quantification accompanied with the proposed color correction method could provide an objective evaluation tool for liver fibrosis, which complements semi-quantitative histologic evaluation systems.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (10) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Research Article:
Computational analysis of p63
+
nuclei distribution pattern by graph theoretic approach in an oral pre-cancer (sub-mucous fibrosis)
Swarnendu Bag, Sailesh Conjeti, Raunak Kumar Das, Mousami Pal, Anji Anura, Ranjan Rashmi Paul, Ajoy Kumar Ray, Sanghamitra Sengupta, Jyotirmoy Chatterjee
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:35 (31 December 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.124006
PMID
:24524001
Background:
Oral submucous fibrosis (OSF) is a pre-cancerous condition with features of chronic, inflammatory and progressive sub-epithelial fibrotic disorder of the buccal mucosa. In this study, malignant potentiality of OSF has been assessed by quantification of immunohistochemical expression of epithelial prime regulator-p63 molecule in correlation to its malignant (oral squamous cell carcinoma [OSCC] and normal counterpart [normal oral mucosa [NOM]). Attributes of spatial extent and distribution of p63
+
expression in the epithelium have been investigated. Further, a correlated assessment of histopathological attributes inferred from H&E staining and their mathematical counterparts (molecular pathology of p63) have been proposed. The suggested analytical framework envisaged standardization of the immunohistochemistry evaluation procedure for the molecular marker, using computer-aided image analysis, toward enhancing its prognostic value.
Subjects
and
Methods:
In histopathologically confirmed OSF, OSCC and NOM tissue sections, p63
+
nuclei were localized and segmented by identifying regional maxima in plateau-like intensity spatial profiles of nuclei. The clustered nuclei were localized and segmented by identifying concave points in the morphometry and by marker-controlled watersheds. Voronoi tessellations were constructed around nuclei centroids and mean values of spatial-relation metrics such as tessellation area, tessellation perimeter, roundness factor and disorder of the area were extracted. Morphology and extent of expression are characterized by area, diameter, perimeter, compactness, eccentricity and density, fraction of p63
+
expression and expression distance of p63
+
nuclei.
Results:
Correlative framework between histopathological features characterizing malignant potentiality and their quantitative p63 counterparts was developed. Statistical analyses of mathematical trends were evaluated between different biologically relevant combinations: (i) NOM to oral submucous fibrosis without dysplasia (OSFWT) (ii) NOM to oral submucous fibrosis with dysplasia (OSFWD) (iii) OSFWT-OSFWD (iv) OSFWD-OSCC. Significant histopathogical correlates and their corroborative mathematical features, inferred from p63 staining, were also investigated into.
Conclusion:
Quantitative assessment and correlative analysis identified mathematical features related to hyperplasia, cellular stratification, differentiation and maturation, shape and size, nuclear crowding and nucleocytoplasmic ratio. It is envisaged that this approach for analyzing the p63 expression and its distribution pattern may help to establish it as a quantitative bio-marker to predict the malignant potentiality and progression. The proposed work would be a value addition to the gold standard by incorporating an observer-independent framework for the associated molecular pathology.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (8) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Applying perceptual and adaptive learning techniques for teaching introductory histopathology
Sally Krasne, Joseph D Hillman, Philip J Kellman, Thomas A Drake
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:34 (31 December 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.123991
PMID
:24524000
Background:
Medical students are expected to master the ability to interpret histopathologic images, a difficult and time-consuming process. A major problem is the issue of transferring information learned from one example of a particular pathology to a new example. Recent advances in cognitive science have identified new approaches to address this problem.
Methods:
We adapted a new approach for enhancing pattern recognition of basic pathologic processes in skin histopathology images that utilizes perceptual learning techniques, allowing learners to see relevant structure in novel cases along with adaptive learning algorithms that space and sequence different categories (e.g. diagnoses) that appear during a learning session based on each learner's accuracy and response time (RT). We developed a perceptual and adaptive learning module (PALM) that utilized 261 unique images of cell injury, inflammation, neoplasia, or normal histology at low and high magnification. Accuracy and RT were tracked and integrated into a "Score" that reflected students rapid recognition of the pathologies and pre- and post-tests were given to assess the effectiveness.
Results:
Accuracy, RT and Scores significantly improved from the pre- to post-test with Scores showing much greater improvement than accuracy alone. Delayed post-tests with previously unseen cases, given after 6-7 weeks, showed a decline in accuracy relative to the post-test for 1
st
-year students, but not significantly so for 2
nd
-year students. However, the delayed post-test scores maintained a significant and large improvement relative to those of the pre-test for both 1
st
and 2
nd
year students suggesting good retention of pattern recognition. Student evaluations were very favorable.
Conclusion:
A web-based learning module based on the principles of cognitive science showed an evidence for improved recognition of histopathology patterns by medical students.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (22) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Laboratory informatics based evaluation of methylene tetrahydrofolate reductase C677T genetic test overutilization
David A Cohen, Brian H Shirts, Brian R Jackson, Lisa S Parker
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:33 (29 November 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.122389
PMID
:24392247
Background:
Laboratory data can provide a wide range of information to estimate adherence to guidelines and proper utilization of genetic testing. The methylene tetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) C677T variant has been demonstrated to have negligible utility in patient management. However, the testing of this variant remains pervasive. The purpose of this study was to develop methods to analyze concordance of clinician ordering practices with national guidelines.
Methods:
We used laboratory data to extract specific data elements including patient demographics, timestamps, physician ordering logs and temporal relationship to chemistry requests to examine 245 consecutive MTHFR tests ordered in 2011 at an academic tertiary center. A comprehensive chart review was used to identify indications for testing. These results were correlated with a retrospective analysis of 4,226 tests drawn at a range of hospitals requesting testing from a national reference laboratory over a 2-year period. MTHFR ordering practices drawn from 17 institutions were examined longitudinally from 2002 to 2011.
Results:
Indications for testing included cerebrovascular events (40.0%) and venous thrombosis (39.1%). Family history prompted testing in eight cases. Based on acceptable hypercoagulability guidelines recommending MTHFR C677T testing only in the presence of elevated serum homocysteine, 10.6% (22/207) of adult patients met an indicated threshold at an academic tertiary center. Among 77 institutions, 14.5% (613/4226) of MTHFR testing met recommendations.
Conclusion:
We demonstrate an effective method to examine discreet elements of a molecular diagnostics laboratory information system at a tertiary care institution and to correlate these findings at a national level. Retrospective examination of clinicians' request of MTHFR C677T genetic testing strongly suggests that clinicians have failed to adjust their ordering practices in light of evolving scientific and professional organization recommendations.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (1) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Research Article:
Needs and workflow assessment prior to implementation of a digital pathology infrastructure for the US Air Force Medical Service
Jonhan Ho, Orly Aridor, David W Glinski, Christopher D Saylor, Joseph P Pelletier, Dale M Selby, Steven W Davis, Nicholas Lancia, Christopher B Gerlach, Jonathan Newberry, Leslie Anthony, Liron Pantanowitz, Anil V Parwani
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:32 (29 November 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.122388
PMID
:24392246
Background:
Advances in digital pathology are accelerating integration of this technology into anatomic pathology (AP). To optimize implementation and adoption of digital pathology systems within a large healthcare organization, initial assessment of both end user (pathologist) needs and organizational infrastructure are required. Contextual inquiry is a qualitative, user-centered tool for collecting, interpreting, and aggregating such detailed data about work practices that can be employed to help identify specific needs and requirements.
Aim:
Using contextual inquiry, the objective of this study was to identify the unique work practices and requirements in AP for the United States (US) Air Force Medical Service (AFMS) that had to be targeted in order to support their transition to digital pathology.
Subjects and Methods:
A pathology-centered observer team conducted 1.5 h interviews with a total of 24 AFMS pathologists and histology lab personnel at three large regional centers and one smaller peripheral AFMS pathology center using contextual inquiry guidelines. Findings were documented as notes and arranged into a hierarchal organization of common themes based on user-provided data, defined as an affinity diagram. These data were also organized into consolidated graphic models that characterized AFMS pathology work practices, structure, and requirements.
Results:
Over 1,200 recorded notes were grouped into an affinity diagram composed of 27 third-level, 10 second-level, and five main-level (workflow and workload distribution, quality, communication, military culture, and technology) categories. When combined with workflow and cultural models, the findings revealed that AFMS pathologists had needs that were unique to their military setting, when compared to civilian pathologists. These unique needs included having to serve a globally distributed patient population, transient staff, but a uniform information technology (IT) structure.
Conclusions:
The contextual inquiry method helped reveal similarities and key differences with civilian pathologists. Such an analysis helped identify specific instances that would benefit from implementing digital pathology in a military environment. Employing digital pathology to facilitate workload distribution, secondary consultations, and quality assurance (over-reads) could help the AFMS deliver more accurate, efficient, and timely AP services at a global level.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (4) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
3D prostate histology image reconstruction: Quantifying the impact of tissue deformation and histology section location
Eli Gibson, Mena Gaed, José A Gómez, Madeleine Moussa, Stephen Pautler, Joseph L Chin, Cathie Crukley, Glenn S Bauman, Aaron Fenster, Aaron D Ward
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:31 (31 October 2013)
PMID
:24392245
Background:
Guidelines for localizing prostate cancer on imaging are ideally informed by registered post-prostatectomy histology. 3D histology reconstruction methods can support this by reintroducing 3D spatial information lost during histology processing. The need to register small, high-grade foci drives a need for high accuracy. Accurate 3D reconstruction method design is impacted by the answers to the following central questions of this work. (1) How does prostate tissue deform during histology processing? (2) What spatial misalignment of the tissue sections is induced by microtome cutting? (3) How does the choice of reconstruction model affect histology reconstruction accuracy?
Materials and Methods:
Histology, paraffin block face and magnetic resonance images were acquired for 18 whole mid-gland tissue slices from six prostates. 7-15 homologous landmarks were identified on each image. Tissue deformation due to histology processing was characterized using the target registration error (TRE) after landmark-based registration under four deformation models (rigid, similarity, affine and thin-plate-spline [TPS]). The misalignment of histology sections from the front faces of tissue slices was quantified using manually identified landmarks. The impact of reconstruction models on the TRE after landmark-based reconstruction was measured under eight reconstruction models comprising one of four deformation models with and without constraining histology images to the tissue slice front faces.
Results:
Isotropic scaling improved the mean TRE by 0.8-1.0 mm (all results reported as 95% confidence intervals), while skew or TPS deformation improved the mean TRE by <0.1 mm. The mean misalignment was 1.1-1.9 (angle) and 0.9-1.3 mm (depth). Using isotropic scaling, the front face constraint raised the mean TRE by 0.6-0.8 mm.
Conclusions:
For sub-millimeter accuracy, 3D reconstruction models should not constrain histology images to the tissue slice front faces and should be flexible enough to model isotropic scaling.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Inter-reader variability in follicular lymphoma grading: Conventional and digital reading
Gerard Lozanski, Michael Pennell, Arwa Shana'ah, Weiqiang Zhao, Amy Gewirtz, Frederick Racke, Eric Hsi, Sabrina Simpson, Claudio Mosse, Shadia Alam, Sharon Swierczynski, Robert P Hasserjian, Metin N Gurcan
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:30 (29 October 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.120747
PMID
:24392244
Context:
Pathologists grade follicular lymphoma (FL) cases by selecting 10, random high power fields (HPFs), counting the number of centroblasts (CBs) in these HPFs under the microscope and then calculating the average CB count for the whole slide. Previous studies have demonstrated that there is high inter-reader variability among pathologists using this methodology in grading.
Aims:
The objective of this study was to explore if newly available digital reading technologies can reduce inter-reader variability.
Settings and Design:
In this study, we considered three different reading conditions (RCs) in grading FL: (1) Conventional (glass-slide based) to establish the baseline, (2) digital whole slide viewing, (3) digital whole slide viewing with selected HPFs. Six board-certified pathologists from five different institutions read 17 FL slides in these three different RCs.
Results:
Although there was relative poor consensus in conventional reading, with lack of consensus in 41.2% of cases, which was similar to previously reported studies; we found that digital reading with pre-selected fields improved the inter-reader agreement, with only 5.9% lacking consensus among pathologists.
Conclusions:
Digital whole slide RC resulted in the worst concordance among pathologists while digital whole slide reading selected HPFs improved the concordance. Further studies are underway to determine if this performance can be sustained with a larger dataset and our automated HPF and CB detection algorithms can be employed to further improve the concordance.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (7) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Development and validation of a tool to evaluate the quality of medical education websites in pathology
Raja H Alyusuf, Kameshwar Prasad, Ali M Abdel Satir, Ali A Abalkhail, Roopa K Arora
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:29 (29 October 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.120729
PMID
:24392243
Background:
The exponential use of the internet as a learning resource coupled with varied quality of many websites, lead to a need to identify suitable websites for teaching purposes.
Aim:
The aim of this study is to develop and to validate a tool, which evaluates the quality of undergraduate medical educational websites; and apply it to the field of pathology.
Methods:
A tool was devised through several steps of item generation, reduction, weightage, pilot testing, post-pilot modification of the tool and validating the tool. Tool validation included measurement of inter-observer reliability; and generation of criterion related, construct related and content related validity. The validated tool was subsequently tested by applying it to a population of pathology websites.
Results and Discussion:
Reliability testing showed a high internal consistency reliability (Cronbach's alpha = 0.92), high inter-observer reliability (Pearson's correlation
r
= 0.88), intraclass correlation coefficient = 0.85 and κ =0.75. It showed high criterion related, construct related and content related validity. The tool showed moderately high concordance with the gold standard (κ =0.61); 92.2% sensitivity, 67.8% specificity, 75.6% positive predictive value and 88.9% negative predictive value. The validated tool was applied to 278 websites; 29.9% were rated as recommended, 41.0% as recommended with caution and 29.1% as not recommended.
Conclusion:
A systematic tool was devised to evaluate the quality of websites for medical educational purposes. The tool was shown to yield reliable and valid inferences through its application to pathology websites.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (8) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Diagnostic digital cytopathology: Are we ready yet?
Jarret C House, Evita B Henderson-Jackson, Joseph O Johnson, Mark C Lloyd, Jasreman Dhillon, Nazeel Ahmad, Ardeshir Hakam, Walid E Khalbuss, Marino E Leon, David Chhieng, Xiaohui Zhang, Barbara A Centeno, Marilyn M Bui
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:28 (29 October 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.120727
PMID
:24392242
Background:
The cytology literature relating to diagnostic accuracy using whole slide imaging is scarce. We studied the diagnostic concordance between glass and digital slides among diagnosticians with different profiles to assess the readiness of adopting digital cytology in routine practice.
Materials and Methods:
This cohort consisted of 22 de-identified previously screened and diagnosed cases, including non-gynecological and gynecological slides using standard preparations. Glass slides were digitalized using Aperio ScanScope XT (×20 and ×40). Cytopathologists with (3) and without (3) digital experience, cytotechnologists (4) and senior pathology residents (2) diagnosed the digital slides independently first and recorded the results. Glass slides were read and recorded separately 1-3 days later. Accuracy of diagnosis, time to diagnosis and diagnostician's profile were analyzed.
Results:
Among 22 case pairs and four study groups, correct diagnosis (93% vs. 86%) was established using glass versus digital slides. Both methods more (>95%) accurately diagnosed positive cases than negatives. Cytopathologists with no digital experience were the most accurate in digital diagnosis, even the senior members. Cytotechnologists had the fastest diagnosis time (3 min/digital vs. 1.7 min/glass), but not the best accuracy. Digital time was 1.5 min longer than glass-slide time/per case for cytopathologists and cytotechnologists. Senior pathology residents were slower and less accurate with both methods. Cytopathologists with digital experience ranked 2
nd
fastest in time, yet last in accuracy for digital slides.
Conclusions:
There was good overall diagnostic agreement between the digital whole-slide images and glass slides. Although glass slide diagnosis was more accurate and faster, the results of technologists and pathologists with no digital cytology experience suggest that solid diagnostic ability is a strong indicator for readiness of digital adoption.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (10) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Technical note:
OpenSlide: A vendor-neutral software foundation for digital pathology
Adam Goode, Benjamin Gilbert, Jan Harkes, Drazen Jukic, Mahadev Satyanarayanan
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:27 (27 September 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.119005
PMID
:24244884
Although widely touted as a replacement for glass slides and microscopes in pathology, digital slides present major challenges in data storage, transmission, processing and interoperability. Since no universal data format is in widespread use for these images today, each vendor defines its own proprietary data formats, analysis tools, viewers and software libraries. This creates issues not only for pathologists, but also for interoperability. In this paper, we present the design and implementation of OpenSlide
,
a vendor-neutral C library for reading and manipulating digital slides of diverse vendor formats. The library is extensible and easily interfaced to various programming languages. An application written to the OpenSlide interface can transparently handle multiple vendor formats. OpenSlide is in use today by many academic and industrial organizations world-wide, including many research sites in the United States that are funded by the National Institutes of Health.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (92) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Full-field optical coherence tomography for the analysis of fresh unstained human lobectomy specimens
Manu Jain, Navneet Narula, Bekheit Salamoon, Maria M Shevchuk, Amit Aggarwal, Nasser Altorki, Brendon Stiles, Claude Boccara, Sushmita Mukherjee
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:26 (27 September 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.119004
PMID
:24244883
Background:
Full-field optical coherence tomography (FFOCT) is a real-time imaging technique that generates high-resolution three-dimensional tomographic images from unprocessed and unstained tissues. Lack of tissue processing and associated artifacts, along with the ability to generate large-field images quickly, warrants its exploration as an alternative diagnostic tool.
Materials
and
Methods:
One section each from the tumor and from adjacent non-neoplastic tissue was collected from 13 human lobectomy specimens. They were imaged fresh with FFOCT and then submitted for routine histopathology. Two blinded pathologists independently rendered diagnoses based on FFOCT images.
Results:
Normal lung architecture (alveoli, bronchi, pleura and blood vessels) was readily identified with FFOCT. Using FFOCT images alone, the study pathologists were able to correctly identify all tumor specimens and in many cases, the histological subtype of tumor (e.g., adenocarcinomas with various patterns). However, benign diagnosis was provided with high confidence in roughly half the tumor-free specimens (others were diagnosed as equivocal or false positive). Further analysis of these images revealed two major confounding features: (a) Extensive lung collapse and (b) presence of smoker's macrophages. On a closer inspection, however, the smoker's macrophages could often be identified as distinct from tumor cells based on their relative location in the alveoli, size and presence of anthracosis. We posit that greater pathologist experience, complemented with morphometric analysis and color-coding of image components, may help minimize the contribution of these confounders in the future.
Conclusion:
Our study provides evidence for the potential utility of FFOCT in identifying and differentiating lung tumors from non-neoplastic lung tissue. We foresee its potential as an adjunct to intra-surgical frozen section analysis for margin assessment, especially in limited lung resections.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (12) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Book review:
Review of "Next-generation DNA sequencing informatics" by Stuart M. Brown (Editor)
Jennifer K Sehn
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:25 (27 September 2013)
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
World's first telepathology experiments employing WINDS ultra-high-speed internet satellite, nicknamed "KIZUNA"
Takashi Sawai, Miwa Uzuki, Yasuhiro Miura, Akihisa Kamataki, Tsubasa Matsumura, Kenji Saito, Akira Kurose, Yoshiyuki R Osamura, Naoki Yoshimi, Hiroyuki Kanno, Takuya Moriya, Yoji Ishida, Yohichi Satoh, Masahiro Nakao, Emiko Ogawa, Satoshi Matsuo, Hiroyuki Kasai, Kazuhiro Kumagai, Toshihiro Motoda, Nathan Hopson
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:24 (27 September 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.119002
PMID
:24244882
Background:
Recent advances in information technology have allowed the development of a telepathology system involving high-speed transfer of high-volume histological figures via fiber optic landlines. However, at present there are geographical limits to landlines. The Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) has developed the "Kizuna" ultra-high speed internet satellite and has pursued its various applications. In this study we experimented with telepathology in collaboration with JAXA using Kizuna. To measure the functionality of the Wideband InterNet working engineering test and Demonstration Satellite (WINDS) ultra-high speed internet satellite in remote pathological diagnosis and consultation, we examined the adequate data transfer speed and stability to conduct telepathology (both diagnosis and conferencing) with functionality, and ease similar or equal to telepathology using fiber-optic landlines.
Materials and Methods:
We performed experiments for 2 years. In year 1, we tested the usability of the WINDS for telepathology with real-time video and virtual slide systems. These are state-of-the-art technologies requiring massive volumes of data transfer. In year 2, we tested the usability of the WINDS for three-way teleconferencing with virtual slides. Facilities in Iwate (northern Japan), Tokyo, and Okinawa were connected via the WINDS and voice conferenced while remotely examining and manipulating virtual slides.
Results:
Network function parameters measured using ping and Iperf were within acceptable limits. However; stage movement, zoom, and conversation suffered a lag of approximately 0.8 s when using real-time video, and a delay of 60-90 s was experienced when accessing the first virtual slide in a session. No significant lag or inconvenience was experienced during diagnosis and conferencing, and the results were satisfactory. Our hypothesis was confirmed for both remote diagnosis using real-time video and virtual slide systems, and also for teleconferencing using virtual slide systems with voice functionality.
Conclusions:
Our results demonstrate the feasibility of ultra-high-speed internet satellite networks for use in telepathology. Because communications satellites have less geographical and infrastructural requirements than landlines, ultra-high-speed internet satellite telepathology represents a major step toward alleviating regional disparity in the quality of medical care.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (1) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Extracting laboratory test information from biomedical text
Yanna Shen Kang, Mehmet Kayaalp
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:23 (31 August 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.117450
PMID
:24083058
Background:
No previous study reported the efficacy of current natural language processing (NLP) methods for extracting laboratory test information from narrative documents. This study investigates the pathology informatics question of how accurately such information can be extracted from text with the current tools and techniques, especially machine learning and symbolic NLP methods. The study data came from a text corpus maintained by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, containing a rich set of information on laboratory tests and test devices.
Methods:
The authors developed a symbolic information extraction (SIE) system to extract device and test specific information about four types of laboratory test entities: Specimens, analytes, units of measures and detection limits. They compared the performance of SIE and three prominent machine learning based NLP systems, LingPipe, GATE and BANNER, each implementing a distinct supervised machine learning method, hidden Markov models, support vector machines and conditional random fields, respectively.
Results:
Machine learning systems recognized laboratory test entities with moderately high recall, but low precision rates. Their recall rates were relatively higher when the number of distinct entity values (e.g., the spectrum of specimens) was very limited or when lexical morphology of the entity was distinctive (as in units of measures), yet SIE outperformed them with statistically significant margins on extracting specimen, analyte and detection limit information in both precision and
F
-measure. Its high recall performance was statistically significant on analyte information extraction.
Conclusions:
Despite its shortcomings against machine learning methods, a well-tailored symbolic system may better discern relevancy among a pile of information of the same type and may outperform a machine learning system by tapping into lexically non-local contextual information such as the document structure.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (2) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Technical note:
Eliminating tissue-fold artifacts in histopathological whole-slide images for improved image-based prediction of cancer grade
Sonal Kothari, John H Phan, May D Wang
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:22 (31 August 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.117448
PMID
:24083057
Background:
Analysis of tissue biopsy whole-slide images (WSIs) depends on effective detection and elimination of image artifacts. We present a novel method to detect tissue-fold artifacts in histopathological WSIs. We also study the effect of tissue folds on image features and prediction models.
Materials
and
Methods:
We use WSIs of samples from two cancer endpoints - kidney clear cell carcinoma (KiCa) and ovarian serous adenocarcinoma (OvCa) - publicly available from The Cancer Genome Atlas. We detect tissue folds in low-resolution WSIs using color properties and two adaptive connectivity-based thresholds. We optimize and validate our tissue-fold detection method using 105 manually annotated WSIs from both cancer endpoints. In addition to detecting tissue folds, we extract 461 image features from the high-resolution WSIs for all samples. We use the rank-sum test to find image features that are statistically different among features extracted from the same set of WSIs with and without folds. We then use features that are affected by tissue folds to develop models for predicting cancer grades.
Results:
When compared to the ground truth, our method detects tissue folds in KiCa with 0.50 adjusted Rand index (ARI), 0.77 average true rate (ATR), 0.55 true positive rate (TPR), and 0.98 true negative rate (TNR); and in OvCa with 0.40 ARI, 0.73 ATR, 0.47 TPR, and 0.98 TNR. Compared to two other methods, our method is more accurate in terms of ARI and ATR. We found that 53 and 30 image features were significantly affected by the presence of tissue-fold artifacts (detected using our method) in OvCa and KiCa, respectively. After eliminating tissue folds, the performance of cancer-grade prediction models improved by 5% and 1% in OvCa and KiCa, respectively.
Conclusion:
The proposed connectivity-based method is more effective in detecting tissue folds compared to other methods. Reducing tissue-fold artifacts will increase the performance of cancer-grade prediction models.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (10) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Review Article:
Relationship between magnification and resolution in digital pathology systems
Tiffany L Sellaro, Robert Filkins, Chelsea Hoffman, Jeffrey L Fine, Jon Ho, Anil V Parwani, Liron Pantanowitz, Michael Montalto
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:21 (22 August 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.116866
PMID
:24083056
Many pathology laboratories are implementing digital pathology systems. The image resolution and scanning (digitization) magnification can vary greatly between these digital pathology systems. In addition, when digital images are compared with viewing images using a microscope, the cellular features can vary in size. This article highlights differences in magnification and resolution between the conventional microscopes and the digital pathology systems. As more pathologists adopt digital pathology, it is important that they understand these differences and how they ultimately translate into what the pathologist can see and how this may impact their overall viewing experience.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (20) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Research Article:
Automated extraction of precise protein expression patterns in lymphoma by text mining abstracts of immunohistochemical studies
Jia-Fu Chang, Mihail Popescu, Gerald L Arthur
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:20 (31 July 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.115880
PMID
:23967385
Background:
In general, surgical pathology reviews report protein expression by tumors in a semi-quantitative manner, that is, -, -/+, +/-, +. At the same time, the experimental pathology literature provides multiple examples of precise expression levels determined by immunohistochemical (IHC) tissue examination of populations of tumors. Natural language processing (NLP) techniques enable the automated extraction of such information through text mining. We propose establishing a database linking quantitative protein expression levels with specific tumor classifications through NLP.
Materials and Methods:
Our method takes advantage of typical forms of representing experimental findings in terms of percentages of protein expression manifest by the tumor population under study. Characteristically, percentages are represented straightforwardly with the % symbol or as the number of positive findings of the total population. Such text is readily recognized using regular expressions and templates permitting extraction of sentences containing these forms for further analysis using grammatical structures and rule-based algorithms.
Results:
Our pilot study is limited to the extraction of such information related to lymphomas. We achieved a satisfactory level of retrieval as reflected in scores of 69.91% precision and 57.25% recall with an
F
-score of 62.95%. In addition, we demonstrate the utility of a web-based curation tool for confirming and correcting our findings.
Conclusions:
The experimental pathology literature represents a rich source of pathobiological information, which has been relatively underutilized. There has been a combinatorial explosion of knowledge within the pathology domain as represented by increasing numbers of immunophenotypes and disease subclassifications. NLP techniques support practical text mining techniques for extracting this knowledge and organizing it in forms appropriate for pathology decision support systems.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (2) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Reproducibility in the automated quantitative assessment of HER2/neu for breast cancer
Tyler Keay, Catherine Conway, Neil O'Flaherty, Stephen M Hewitt, Katherine Shea, Marios A Gavrielides
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:19 (31 July 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.115879
PMID
:23967384
Background:
With the emerging role of digital imaging in pathology and the application of automated image-based algorithms to a number of quantitative tasks, there is a need to examine factors that may affect the reproducibility of results. These factors include the imaging properties of whole slide imaging (WSI) systems and their effect on the performance of quantitative tools. This manuscript examines inter-scanner and inter-algorithm variability in the assessment of the commonly used HER2/neu tissue-based biomarker for breast cancer with emphasis on the effect of algorithm training.
Materials and Methods:
A total of 241 regions of interest from 64 breast cancer tissue glass slides were scanned using three different whole-slide images and were analyzed using two different automated image analysis algorithms, one with preset parameters and another incorporating a procedure for objective parameter optimization. Ground truth from a panel of seven pathologists was available from a previous study. Agreement analysis was used to compare the resulting HER2/neu scores.
Results:
The results of our study showed that inter-scanner agreement in the assessment of HER2/neu for breast cancer in selected fields of view when analyzed with any of the two algorithms examined in this study was equal or better than the inter-observer agreement previously reported on the same set of data. Results also showed that discrepancies observed between algorithm results on data from different scanners were significantly reduced when the alternative algorithm that incorporated an objective re-training procedure was used, compared to the commercial algorithm with preset parameters.
Conclusion:
Our study supports the use of objective procedures for algorithm training to account for differences in image properties between WSI systems.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (10) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Commentary:
What is new in the evaluation of diagnostic digital cytopathology in cervicovaginal smears?
Marilyn M Bui, Corinne L Stephenson
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:18 (31 July 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.115874
PMID
:23967386
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (2) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Book review:
Review of "Digital image forensics: There is more to a picture than meets the eye" by Husrev Taha Sencar and Nasir Memon (Editors)
Bruce Levy
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:17 (29 June 2013)
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Platelet count estimation using the CellaVision DM96 system
Yuon Gao, Adnan Mansoor, Brenda Wood, Heather Nelson, Diane Higa, Christopher Naugler
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:16 (29 June 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.114207
PMID
:23858391
Introduction:
Rapid and accurate determination of platelet count is an important factor in diagnostic medicine. Traditional microscopic methods are labor intensive with variable results and are highly dependent on the individual training. Recent developments in automated peripheral blood differentials using a computerized system have shown many advantages as a viable alternative. The purpose of this paper was to determine the reliability and accuracy of the CellaVision DM 96 system with regards to platelet counts.
Materials and
Methods:
One hundred twenty seven peripheral blood smears were analyzed for platelet count by manual microscopy, an automated hematology analyzer (Beckman Counter LH 780 or Unicel DXH 800 analyzers) and with the CellaVision DM96 system. Results were compared using the correlations and Bland-Altman plots.
Results:
Platelet counts from the DM96 system showed an R
2
of 0.94 when compared to manual platelet estimates and an R
2
of 0.92 when compared to the automated hematology analyzer results. Bland-Altman plots did not show any systematic bias.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (6) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Review Article:
Going fully digital: Perspective of a Dutch academic pathology lab
Nikolas Stathonikos, Mitko Veta, André Huisman, Paul J van Diest
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:15 (29 June 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.114206
PMID
:23858390
During the last years, whole slide imaging has become more affordable and widely accepted in pathology labs. Digital slides are increasingly being used for digital archiving of routinely produced clinical slides, remote consultation and tumor boards, and quantitative image analysis for research purposes and in education. However, the implementation of a fully digital Pathology Department requires an in depth look into the suitability of digital slides for routine clinical use (the image quality of the produced digital slides and the factors that affect it) and the required infrastructure to support such use (the storage requirements and integration with lab management and hospital information systems). Optimization of digital pathology workflow requires communication between several systems, which can be facilitated by the use of open standards for digital slide storage and scanner management. Consideration of these aspects along with appropriate validation of the use of digital slides for routine pathology can pave the way for pathology departments to go "fully digital." In this paper, we summarize our experiences so far in the process of implementing a fully digital workflow at our Pathology Department and the steps that are needed to complete this process.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (53) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Research Article:
Performance of CellaVision DM96 in leukocyte classification
Lik Hang Lee, Adnan Mansoor, Brenda Wood, Heather Nelson, Diane Higa, Christopher Naugler
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:14 (29 June 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.114205
PMID
:23858389
Background:
Leukocyte differentials are an important component of clinical care. Morphologic assessment of peripheral blood smears (PBS) may be required to accurately classify leukocytes. However, manual microscopy is labor intensive. The CellaVision DM96 is an automated system that acquires digital images of leukocytes on PBS, pre-classifies the cell type, and displays them on screen for a Technologist or Pathologist to approve or reclassify. Our study compares the results of the DM96 with manual microscopy.
Methods:
Three hundred and fifty-nine PBS were selected and assessed by manual microscopy with a 200 leukocyte cell count. They were then reassessed using the CellaVision DM96 with a 115 leukocyte cell count including reclassification when necessary. Correlation between the manual microscopy results and the CellaVision DM96 results was calculated for each cell type.
Results:
The correlation coefficients (
r
2
) range from a high of 0.99 for blasts to a low of 0.72 for metamyelocytes.
Conclusions:
The correlation between the CellaVision DM96 and manual microscopy was as good or better than the previously published data. The accuracy of leukocyte classification depended on the cell type, and in general, there was lower correlation for rare cell types. However, the correlation is similar to previous studies on the correlation of manual microscopy with an established reference result. Therefore, the CellaVision DM96 is appropriate for clinical implementation.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (17) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Editorial:
The (not yet) willingly adopted tool
Lewis A Hassell, Eric Glassy
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:13 (29 June 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.114204
PMID
:23858388
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (3) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Article:
Mitosis detection using generic features and an ensemble of cascade adaboosts
F Boray Tek
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:12 (30 May 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.112697
PMID
:23858387
Context:
Mitosis count is one of the factors that pathologists use to assess the risk of metastasis and survival of the patients, which are affected by the breast cancer.
Aims:
We investigate an application of a set of generic features and an ensemble of cascade adaboosts to the automated mitosis detection. Calculation of the features rely minimally on object-level descriptions and thus require minimal segmentation.
Materials and Methods:
The proposed work was developed and tested on International Conference on Pattern Recognition (ICPR) 2012 mitosis detection contest data.
Statistical Analysis Used:
We plotted receiver operating characteristics curves of true positive versus false positive rates; calculated recall, precision, F-measure, and region overlap ratio measures.
Results:
We tested our features with two different classifier configurations: 1) An ensemble of single adaboosts, 2) an ensemble of cascade adaboosts. On the ICPR 2012 mitosis detection contest evaluation, the cascade ensemble scored 54, 62.7, and 58, whereas the non-cascade version scored 68, 28.1, and 39.7 for the recall, precision, and F-measure measures, respectively. Mostly used features in the adaboost classifier rules were a shape-based feature, which counted granularity and a color-based feature, which relied on Red, Green, and Blue channel statistics.
Conclusions:
The features, which express the granular structure and color variations, are found useful for mitosis detection. The ensemble of adaboosts performs better than the individual adaboost classifiers. Moreover, the ensemble of cascaded adaboosts was better than the ensemble of single adaboosts for mitosis detection.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (21) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Article:
A gamma-gaussian mixture model for detection of mitotic cells in breast cancer histopathology images
Adnan Mujahid Khan, Hesham ElDaly, Nasir M Rajpoot
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:11 (30 May 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.112696
PMID
:23858386
In this paper, we propose a statistical approach for mitosis detection in breast cancer histological images. The proposed algorithm models the pixel intensities in mitotic and non-mitotic regions by a Gamma-Gaussian mixture model (GGMM) and employs a context aware post-processing (CAPP) in order to reduce false positives. Experimental results demonstrate the ability of this simple, yet effective method to detect mitotic cells (MCs) in standard H & E breast cancer histology images.
Context:
Counting of MCs in breast cancer histopathology images is one of three components (the other two being tubule formation, nuclear pleomorphism) required for developing computer assisted grading of breast cancer tissue slides. This is very challenging since the biological variability of the MCs makes their detection extremely difficult. In addition, if standard H & E is used (which stains chromatin rich structures, such as nucleus, apoptotic, and MCs dark blue) and it becomes extremely difficult to detect the latter given the fact that former two are densely localized in the tissue sections.
Aims:
In this paper, a robust MCs detection technique is developed and tested on 35 breast histopathology images, belonging to five different tissue slides.
Settings and Design:
Our approach mimics a pathologists' approach to MCs detections. The idea is (1) to isolate tumor areas from non-tumor areas (lymphoid/inflammatory/apoptotic cells), (2) search for MCs in the reduced space by statistically modeling the pixel intensities from mitotic and non-mitotic regions, and finally (3) evaluate the context of each potential MC in terms of its texture.
Materials and Methods:
Our experimental dataset consisted of 35 digitized images of breast cancer biopsy slides with paraffin embedded sections stained with H and E and scanned at × 40 using an Aperio scanscope slide scanner.
Statistical Analysis Used:
We propose GGMM for detecting MCs in breast histology images. Image intensities are modeled as random variables sampled from one of the two distributions; Gamma and Gaussian. Intensities from MCs are modeled by a gamma distribution and those from non-mitotic regions are modeled by a gaussian distribution. The choice of Gamma-Gaussian distribution is mainly due to the observation that the characteristics of the distribution match well with the data it models. The experimental results show that the proposed system achieves a high sensitivity of 0.82 with positive predictive value (PPV) of 0.29. Employing CAPP on these results produce 241% increase in PPV at the cost of less than 15% decrease in sensitivity.
Conclusions:
In this paper, we presented a GGMM for detection of MCs in breast cancer histopathological images. In addition, we introduced CAPP as a tool to increase the PPV with a minimal loss in sensitivity. We evaluated the performance of the proposed detection algorithm in terms of sensitivity and PPV over a set of 35 breast histology images selected from five different tissue slides and showed that a reasonably high value of sensitivity can be retained while increasing the PPV. Our future work will aim at increasing the PPV further by modeling the spatial appearance of regions surrounding mitotic events.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (16) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Article:
Automated mitosis detection in histopathology using morphological and multi-channel statistics features
Humayun Irshad
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:10 (30 May 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.112695
PMID
:23858385
Context:
According to Nottingham grading system, mitosis count plays a critical role in cancer diagnosis and grading. Manual counting of mitosis is tedious and subject to considerable inter- and intra-reader variations.
Aims:
The aim is to improve the accuracy of mitosis detection by selecting the color channels that better capture the statistical and morphological features, which classify mitosis from other objects.
Materials and Methods:
We propose a framework that includes comprehensive analysis of statistics and morphological features in selected channels of various color spaces that assist pathologists in mitosis detection. In candidate detection phase, we perform Laplacian of Gaussian, thresholding, morphology and active contour model on blue-ratio image to detect and segment candidates. In candidate classification phase, we extract a total of 143 features including morphological, first order and second order (texture) statistics features for each candidate in selected channels and finally classify using decision tree classifier.
Results and
Discussion:
The proposed method has been evaluated on Mitosis Detection in Breast Cancer Histological Images (MITOS) dataset provided for an International Conference on Pattern Recognition 2012 contest and achieved 74% and 71% detection rate, 70% and 56% precision and 72% and 63% F-Measure on Aperio and Hamamatsu images, respectively.
Conclusions and Future Work:
The proposed multi-channel features computation scheme uses fixed image scale and extracts nuclei features in selected channels of various color spaces. This simple but robust model has proven to be highly efficient in capturing multi-channels statistical features for mitosis detection, during the MITOS international benchmark. Indeed, the mitosis detection of critical importance in cancer diagnosis is a very challenging visual task. In future work, we plan to use color deconvolution as preprocessing and Hough transform or local extrema based candidate detection in order to reduce the number of candidates in mitosis and non-mitosis classes.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (46) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Article:
Classification of mitotic figures with convolutional neural networks and seeded blob features
Christopher D Malon, Eric Cosatto
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:9 (30 May 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.112694
PMID
:23858384
Background:
The mitotic figure recognition contest at the 2012 International Conference on Pattern Recognition (ICPR) challenges a system to identify all mitotic figures in a region of interest of hematoxylin and eosin stained tissue, using each of three scanners (Aperio, Hamamatsu, and multispectral).
Methods:
Our approach combines manually designed nuclear features with the learned features extracted by convolutional neural networks (CNN). The nuclear features capture color, texture, and shape information of segmented regions around a nucleus. The use of a CNN handles the variety of appearances of mitotic figures and decreases sensitivity to the manually crafted features and thresholds.
Results
: On the test set provided by the contest, the trained system achieves F1 scores up to 0.659 on color scanners and 0.589 on multispectral scanner.
Conclusions
: We demonstrate a powerful technique combining segmentation-based features with CNN, identifying the majority of mitotic figures with a fair precision. Further, we show that the approach accommodates information from the additional focal planes and spectral bands from a multi-spectral scanner without major redesign.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (65) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Article:
Mitosis detection in breast cancer histological images An ICPR 2012 contest
Ludovic Roux, Daniel Racoceanu, Nicolas Loménie, Maria Kulikova, Humayun Irshad, Jacques Klossa, Frédérique Capron, Catherine Genestie, Gilles Le Naour, Metin N Gurcan
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:8 (30 May 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.112693
PMID
:23858383
Introduction:
In the framework of the Cognitive Microscope (MICO) project, we have set up a contest about mitosis detection in images of H and E stained slides of breast cancer for the conference ICPR 2012. Mitotic count is an important parameter for the prognosis of breast cancer. However, mitosis detection in digital histopathology is a challenging problem that needs a deeper study. Indeed, mitosis detection is difficult because mitosis are small objects with a large variety of shapes, and they can thus be easily confused with some other objects or artefacts present in the image. We added a further dimension to the contest by using two different slide scanners having different resolutions and producing red-green-blue (RGB) images, and a multi-spectral microscope producing images in 10 different spectral bands and 17 layers Z-stack. 17 teams participated in the study and the best team achieved a recall rate of 0.7 and precision of 0.89.
Context:
Several studies on automatic tools to process digitized slides have been reported focusing mainly on nuclei or tubule detection. Mitosis detection is a challenging problem that has not yet been addressed well in the literature.
Aims:
Mitotic count is an important parameter in breast cancer grading as it gives an evaluation of the aggressiveness of the tumor. However, consistency, reproducibility and agreement on mitotic count for the same slide can vary largely among pathologists. An automatic tool for this task may help for reaching a better consistency, and at the same time reducing the burden of this demanding task for the pathologists.
Subjects and Methods:
Professor Frιdιrique Capron team of the pathology department at Pitiι-Salpκtriθre Hospital in Paris, France, has selected a set of five slides of breast cancer. The slides are stained with H and E. They have been scanned by three different equipments: Aperio ScanScope XT slide scanner, Hamamatsu NanoZoomer 2.0-HT slide scanner and 10 bands multispectral microscope. The data set is made up of 50 high power fields (HPF) coming from 5 different slides scanned at ×40 magnification. There are 10 HPFs/slide. The pathologist has annotated all the mitotic cells manually. A HPF has a size of 512 μm × 512 μm (that is an area of 0.262 mm
2
, which is a surface equivalent to that of a microscope field diameter of 0.58 mm. These 50 HPFs contain a total of 326 mitotic cells on images of both scanners, and 322 mitotic cells on the multispectral microscope.
Results
: Up to 129 teams have registered to the contest. However, only 17 teams submitted their detection of mitotic cells. The performance of the best team is very promising, with F-measure as high as 0.78. However, the database we provided is by far too small for a good assessment of reliability and robustness of the proposed algorithms.
Conclusions
: Mitotic count is an important criterion in the grading of many types of cancers, however, very little research has been made on automatic mitotic cell detection, mainly because of a lack of available data. A main objective of this contest was to propose a database of mitotic cells on digitized breast cancer histopathology slides to initiate works on automated mitotic cell detection. In the future, we would like to extend this database to have much more images from different patients and also for different types of cancers. In addition, mitotic cells should be annotated by several pathologists to reflect the partial agreement among them.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (87) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
The history of pathology informatics: A global perspective
Seung Park, Anil V Parwani, Raymond D Aller, Lech Banach, Michael J Becich, Stephan Borkenfeld, Alexis B Carter, Bruce A Friedman, Marcial Garcia Rojo, Andrew Georgiou, Gian Kayser, Klaus Kayser, Michael Legg, Christopher Naugler, Takashi Sawai, Hal Weiner, Dennis Winsten, Liron Pantanowitz
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:7 (30 May 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.112689
PMID
:23869286
Pathology informatics has evolved to varying levels around the world. The history of pathology informatics in different countries is a tale with many dimensions. At first glance, it is the familiar story of individuals solving problems that arise in their clinical practice to enhance efficiency, better manage (e.g., digitize) laboratory information, as well as exploit emerging information technologies. Under the surface, however, lie powerful resource, regulatory, and societal forces that helped shape our discipline into what it is today. In this monograph, for the first time in the history of our discipline, we collectively perform a global review of the field of pathology informatics. In doing so, we illustrate how general far-reaching trends such as the advent of computers, the Internet and digital imaging have affected pathology informatics in the world at large. Major drivers in the field included the need for pathologists to comply with national standards for health information technology and telepathology applications to meet the scarcity of pathology services and trained people in certain countries. Following trials by a multitude of investigators, not all of them successful, it is apparent that innovation alone did not assure the success of many informatics tools and solutions. Common, ongoing barriers to the widespread adoption of informatics devices include poor information technology infrastructure in undeveloped areas, the cost of technology, and regulatory issues. This review offers a deeper understanding of how pathology informatics historically developed and provides insights into what the promising future might hold.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (20) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Review Article:
A meta-analysis of telemedicine success in Africa
Dan S Wamala, Kaddu Augustine
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:6 (30 May 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.112686
PMID
:23858382
The use of information and communication technologies (ICT) tools to improve the efficiency of professionalism at work is increasing every time under the dynamic digital environment. Tools such as telemedicine, tele-education, and health informatics have of late been incorporated in the health sector to enable easy access to essential services, for example, in medical areas from referral centers by the patients on one hand and enabling the doctor to doctor consultations for the benefit of patients. Unfortunately, observations indicate dearth efforts and commitment to optimize use of the tools in the majority of the countries south of the Sahara. Sub-Saharan Africa has been left almost behind the rest of the world in terms of development going through decades of economic exploitation by especially the west through its natural and human resources. These factors, ethnic conflicts and endless wars have continued to ruin sub-Saharan Africa's socio-economic development. Information was obtained through a network of telemedicine practitioners in different African countries using internet communication, through E-mail and reviewing existing literature of their activities. This information was compiled from representative countries in each African region and the previous authors'experiences as telemedicine practioners. Most of these countries have inadequate ICT infrastructure, which yet creates sub-optimal application. Sub-Saharan Africa, made up of 33 of the 48 global poorest countries has to extend its ICT diffusion and policy to match the ever developing global economy. In some countries such as Ethiopia and South Africa there is significant progress in Telemedicine while in countries such as Burkina Faso and Nigeria the progress is slow because of lack of political support. Almost all reference to Africa is made in due respect to sub-Saharan Africa, one with big social, economic, and political problems with resultant high morbidity and mortality rates. This also highlights the under-representation of African researchers in the global whelm of information system research. Telemedicine in Africa though has not attracted enough political support is potentially a very useful conduit of health-care given the fact that the continent is resource limited and still enduring the effects of scarce human resource especially in health.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (31) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
Scalable system for classification of white blood cells from Leishman stained blood stain images
Atin Mathur, Ardhendu S Tripathi, Manohar Kuse
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:15 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109883
PMID
:23766937
Introduction:
The White Blood Cell (WBC) differential count yields clinically relevant information about health and disease. Currently, pathologists manually annotate the WBCs, which is time consuming and susceptible to error, due to the tedious nature of the process. This study aims at automation of the Differential Blood Count (DBC) process, so as to increase productivity and eliminate human errors.
Materials and Methods:
The proposed system takes the peripheral Leishman blood stain images as the input and generates a count for each of the WBC subtypes. The digitized microscopic images are stain normalized for the segmentation, to be consistent over a diverse set of slide images. Active contours are employed for robust segmentation of the WBC nucleus and cytoplasm. The seed points are generated by processing the images in Hue-Saturation-Value (HSV) color space. An efficient method for computing a new feature, 'number of lobes,' for discrimination of WBC subtypes, is introduced in this article. This method is based on the concept of minimization of the compactness of each lobe. The Naive Bayes classifier, with Laplacian correction, provides a fast, efficient, and robust solution to multiclass categorization problems. This classifier is characterized by incremental learning and can also be embedded within the database systems.
Results:
An overall accuracy of 92.45% and 92.72% over the training and testing sets has been obtained, respectively.
Conclusion:
Thus, incremental learning is inducted into the Naive Bayes Classifier, to facilitate fast, robust, and efficient classification, which is evident from the high sensitivity achieved for all the subtypes of WBCs.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (14) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
Automated classification of immunostaining patterns in breast tissue from the human protein Atlas
Issac Niwas Swamidoss, Andreas Kårsnäs, Virginie Uhlmann, Palanisamy Ponnusamy, Caroline Kampf, Martin Simonsson, Carolina Wählby, Robin Strand
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:14 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109881
PMID
:23766936
Background:
The Human Protein Atlas (HPA) is an effort to map the location of all human proteins (http://www.proteinatlas.org/). It contains a large number of histological images of sections from human tissue. Tissue micro arrays (TMA) are imaged by a slide scanning microscope, and each image represents a thin slice of a tissue core with a dark brown antibody specific stain and a blue counter stain. When generating antibodies for protein profiling of the human proteome, an important step in the quality control is to compare staining patterns of different antibodies directed towards the same protein. This comparison is an ultimate control that the antibody recognizes the right protein. In this paper, we propose and evaluate different approaches for classifying sub-cellular antibody staining patterns in breast tissue samples.
Materials and Methods:
The proposed methods include the computation of various features including gray level co-occurrence matrix (GLCM) features, complex wavelet co-occurrence matrix (CWCM) features, and weighted neighbor distance using compound hierarchy of algorithms representing morphology (WND-CHARM)-inspired features. The extracted features are used into two different multivariate classifiers (support vector machine (SVM) and linear discriminant analysis (LDA) classifier). Before extracting features, we use color deconvolution to separate different tissue components, such as the brownly stained positive regions and the blue cellular regions, in the immuno-stained TMA images of breast tissue.
Results:
We present classification results based on combinations of feature measurements. The proposed complex wavelet features and the WND-CHARM features have accuracy similar to that of a human expert.
Conclusions:
Both human experts and the proposed automated methods have difficulties discriminating between nuclear and cytoplasmic staining patterns. This is to a large extent due to mixed staining of nucleus and cytoplasm. Methods for quantification of staining patterns in histopathology have many applications, ranging from antibody quality control to tumor grading.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (10) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
Immunohistochemical analysis of breast tissue microarray images using contextual classifiers
Stephen J McKenna, Telmo Amaral, Shazia Akbar, Lee Jordan, Alastair Thompson
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:13 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109871
PMID
:23766935
Background:
Tissue microarrays (TMAs) are an important tool in translational research for examining multiple cancers for molecular and protein markers. Automatic immunohistochemical (IHC) scoring of breast TMA images remains a challenging problem.
Methods:
A two-stage approach that involves localization of regions of invasive and
in-situ
carcinoma followed by ordinal IHC scoring of nuclei in these regions is proposed. The localization stage classifies locations on a grid as tumor or non-tumor based on local image features. These classifications are then refined using an auto-context algorithm called spin-context. Spin-context uses a series of classifiers to integrate image feature information with spatial context information in the form of estimated class probabilities. This is achieved in a rotationally-invariant manner. The second stage estimates ordinal IHC scores in terms of the strength of staining and the proportion of nuclei stained. These estimates take the form of posterior probabilities, enabling images with uncertain scores to be referred for pathologist review.
Results:
The method was validated against manual pathologist scoring on two nuclear markers, progesterone receptor (PR) and estrogen receptor (ER). Errors for PR data were consistently lower than those achieved with ER data. Scoring was in terms of estimated proportion of cells that were positively stained (scored on an ordinal scale of 0-6) and perceived strength of staining (scored on an ordinal scale of 0-3). Average absolute differences between predicted scores and pathologist-assigned scores were 0.74 for proportion of cells and 0.35 for strength of staining (PR).
Conclusions:
The use of context information via spin-context improved the precision and recall of tumor localization. The combination of the spin-context localization method with the automated scoring method resulted in reduced IHC scoring errors.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (4) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
Automated mitosis detection using texture, SIFT features and HMAX biologically inspired approach
Humayun Irshad, Sepehr Jalali, Ludovic Roux, Daniel Racoceanu, Lim Joo Hwee, Gilles Le Naour, Frédérique Capron
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:12 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109870
PMID
:23766934
Context:
According to Nottingham grading system, mitosis count in breast cancer histopathology is one of three components required for cancer grading and prognosis. Manual counting of mitosis is tedious and subject to considerable inter- and intra-reader variations.
Aims:
The aim is to investigate the various texture features and Hierarchical Model and X (HMAX) biologically inspired approach for mitosis detection using machine-learning techniques.
Materials and Methods:
We propose an approach that assists pathologists in automated mitosis detection and counting. The proposed method, which is based on the most favorable texture features combination, examines the separability between different channels of color space. Blue-ratio channel provides more discriminative information for mitosis detection in histopathological images. Co-occurrence features, run-length features, and Scale-invariant feature transform (SIFT) features were extracted and used in the classification of mitosis. Finally, a classification is performed to put the candidate patch either in the mitosis class or in the non-mitosis class. Three different classifiers have been evaluated: Decision tree, linear kernel Support Vector Machine (SVM), and non-linear kernel SVM. We also evaluate the performance of the proposed framework using the modified biologically inspired model of HMAX and compare the results with other feature extraction methods such as dense SIFT.
Results:
The proposed method has been tested on Mitosis detection in breast cancer histological images (MITOS) dataset provided for an International Conference on Pattern Recognition (ICPR) 2012 contest. The proposed framework achieved 76% recall, 75% precision and 76% F-measure.
Conclusions:
Different frameworks for classification have been evaluated for mitosis detection. In future work, instead of regions, we intend to compute features on the results of mitosis contour segmentation and use them to improve detection and classification rate.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (27) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Histological stain evaluation for machine learning applications
Jimmy C Azar, Christer Busch, Ingrid B Carlbom
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:11 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109869
PMID
:23766933
Aims:
A methodology for quantitative comparison of histological stains based on their classification and clustering performance, which may facilitate the choice of histological stains for automatic pattern and image analysis.
Background:
Machine learning and image analysis are becoming increasingly important in pathology applications for automatic analysis of histological tissue samples. Pathologists rely on multiple, contrasting stains to analyze tissue samples, but histological stains are developed for visual analysis and are not always ideal for automatic analysis.
Materials and Methods:
Thirteen different histological stains were used to stain adjacent prostate tissue sections from radical prostatectomies. We evaluate the stains for both supervised and unsupervised classification of stain/tissue combinations. For supervised classification we measure the error rate of nonlinear support vector machines, and for unsupervised classification we use the Rand index and the F-measure to assess the clustering results of a Gaussian mixture model based on expectation-maximization. Finally, we investigate class separability measures based on scatter criteria.
Results:
A methodology for quantitative evaluation of histological stains in terms of their classification and clustering efficacy that aims at improving segmentation and color decomposition. We demonstrate that for a specific tissue type, certain stains perform consistently better than others according to objective error criteria.
Conclusions:
The choice of histological stain for automatic analysis must be based on its classification and clustering performance, which are indicators of the performance of automatic segmentation of tissue into morphological components, which in turn may be the basis for diagnosis.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (2) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
Registration of histological whole slide images guided by vessel structures
Michael Schwier, Tobias Böhler, Horst Karl Hahn, Uta Dahmen, Olaf Dirsch
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:10 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109868
PMID
:23766932
Introduction:
The registration of histological whole slide images is an important prerequisite for modern histological image analysis. A partial reconstruction of the original volume allows e.g. colocalization analysis of tissue parameters or high-detail reconstructions of anatomical structures in 3D.
Methods:
In this paper, we present an automatic staining-invariant registration method, and as part of that, introduce a novel vessel-based rigid registration algorithm using a custom similarity measure. The method is based on an iterative best-fit matching of prominent vessel structures.
Results:
We evaluated our method on a sophisticated synthetic dataset as well as on real histological whole slide images. Based on labeled vessel structures we compared the relative differences for corresponding structures. The average positional error was close to 0, the median for the size change factor was 1, and the median overlap was 0.77.
Conclusion:
The results show that our approach is very robust and creates high quality reconstructions. The key element for the resulting quality is our novel rigid registration algorithm.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (13) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
Real-time whole slide mosaicing for non-automated microscopes in histopathology analysis
Alessandro Gherardi, Alessandro Bevilacqua
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:9 (30 March 2013)
PMID
:23766945
Context:
Mosaics of Whole Slides (WS) are a valuable resource for pathologists to have the whole sample available at high resolution. The WS mosaic provides pathologists with an overview of the whole sample at a glance, helping them to make a reliable diagnosis. Despite recent solutions exist for creating WS mosaics based, for instance, on automated microscopes with motorized stages or WS scanner, most of the histopathology analysis are still performed in laboratories endowed with standard manual stage microscopes. Nowadays, there are lots of dedicated devices and hardware to achieve WS automatically and in batch, but only few of them are conceived to work tightly connected with a microscope and none of them is capable of working in real-time with common light microscopes. However, there is a need of having low-cost yet effective mosaicing applications even in small laboratories to improve routine histopathological analyses or to perform remote diagnoses.
Aims:
The purpose of this work is to study and develop a real-time mosaicing algorithm working even using non-automated microscopes, to enable pathologists to achieve WS while moving the holder manually, without exploiting any dedicated device. This choice enables pathologists to build WS in real-time, while browsing the sample as they are accustomed to, helping them to identify, locate, and digitally annotate lesions fast.
Materials and Methods:
Our method exploits fast feature tracker and frame to frame registration that we implemented on common graphics processing unit cards. The system work with common light microscopes endowed with a digital camera and connected to a commodity personal computer.
Result and Conclusion:
The system has been tested on several histological samples to test the effectiveness of the algorithm to work with mosaicing having different appearances as far as brightness, contrast, texture, and detail levels are concerned, attaining sub-pixel registration accuracy at real-time interactive rates.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
Quantifying local heterogeneity via morphologic scale: Distinguishing tumoral from stromal regions
Andrew Janowczyk, Sharat Chandran, Anant Madabhushi
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:8 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109865
PMID
:23766944
Introduction:
The notion of local scale was introduced to characterize varying levels of image detail so that localized image processing tasks could be performed while simultaneously yielding a globally optimal result. In this paper, we have presented the methodological framework for a novel locally adaptive scale definition, morphologic scale (MS), which is different from extant local scale definitions in that it attempts to characterize local heterogeneity as opposed to local homogeneity.
Methods:
At every point of interest, the MS is determined as a series of radial paths extending outward in the direction of least resistance, navigating around obstructions. Each pixel can then be directly compared to other points of interest via a rotationally invariant quantitative feature descriptor, determined by the application of Fourier descriptors to the collection of these paths.
Results:
Our goal is to distinguish tumor and stromal tissue classes in the context of four different digitized pathology datasets: prostate tissue microarrays (TMAs) stained with hematoxylin and eosin (HE) (44 images) and TMAs stained with only hematoxylin (H) (44 images), slide mounts of ovarian H (60 images), and HE breast cancer (51 images) histology images. Classification performance over 50 cross-validation runs using a Bayesian classifier produced mean areas under the curve of 0.88 ± 0.01 (prostate HE), 0.87 ± 0.02 (prostate H), 0.88 ± 0.01 (ovarian H), and 0.80 ± 0.01 (breast HE).
Conclusion:
For each dataset listed in [Table 3], we randomly selected 100 points per image, and using the procedure described in Experiment 1, we attempted to separate them as belonging to stroma or epithelium.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (1) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
3D reconstruction of multiple stained histology images
Yi Song, Darren Treanor, Andrew J Bulpitt, Derek R Magee
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:7 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109864
PMID
:23766943
Context:
Three dimensional (3D) tissue reconstructions from the histology images with different stains allows the spatial alignment of structural and functional elements highlighted by different stains for quantitative study of many physiological and pathological phenomena. This has significant potential to improve the understanding of the growth patterns and the spatial arrangement of diseased cells, and enhance the study of biomechanical behavior of the tissue structures towards better treatments (e.g. tissue-engineering applications).
Methods:
This paper evaluates three strategies for 3D reconstruction from sets of two dimensional (2D) histological sections with different stains, by combining methods of 2D multi-stain registration and 3D volumetric reconstruction from same stain sections.
Setting and Design:
The different strategies have been evaluated on two liver specimens (80 sections in total) stained with Hematoxylin and Eosin (H and E), Sirius Red, and Cytokeratin (CK) 7.
Results and Conclusion:
A strategy of using multi-stain registration to align images of a second stain to a volume reconstructed by same-stain registration results in the lowest overall error, although an interlaced image registration approach may be more robust to poor section quality.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (24) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
Stain guided mean-shift filtering in automatic detection of human tissue nuclei
Yu Zhou, Derek Magee, Darren Treanor, Andrew Bulpitt
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:6 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109863
PMID
:23766942
Background:
As a critical technique in a digital pathology laboratory, automatic nuclear detection has been investigated for more than one decade. Conventional methods work on the raw images directly whose color/intensity homogeneity within tissue/cell areas are undermined due to artefacts such as uneven staining, making the subsequent binarization process prone to error. This paper concerns detecting cell nuclei automatically from digital pathology images by enhancing the color homogeneity as a pre-processing step.
Methods:
Unlike previous watershed based algorithms relying on post-processing of the watershed, we present a new method that incorporates the staining information of pathological slides in the analysis. This pre-processing step strengthens the color homogeneity within the nuclear areas as well as the background areas, while keeping the nuclear edges sharp. Proof of convergence for the proposed algorithm is also provided. After pre-processing, Otsu's threshold is applied to binarize the image, which is further segmented via watershed. To keep a proper compromise between removing overlapping and avoiding over-segmentation, a naive Bayes classifier is designed to refine the splits suggested by the watershed segmentation.
Results:
The method is validated with 10 sets of 1000 × 1000 pathology images of lymphoma from one digital slide. The mean precision and recall rates are 87% and 91%, corresponding to a mean F-score equal to 89%. Standard deviations for these performance indicators are 5.1%, 1.6% and 3.2% respectively.
Conclusion:
The precision/recall performance obtained indicates that the proposed method outperforms several other alternatives. In particular, for nuclear detection, stain guided mean-shift (SGMS) is more effective than the direct application of mean-shift in pre-processing. Our experiments also show that pre-processing the digital pathology images with SGMS gives better results than conventional watershed algorithms. Nevertheless, as only one type of tissue is tested in this paper, a further study is planned to enhance the robustness of the algorithm so that other types of tissues/stains can also be processed reliably.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (5) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
Approaches to automatic parameter fitting in a microscopy image segmentation pipeline: An exploratory parameter space analysis
Christian Held, Tim Nattkemper, Ralf Palmisano, Thomas Wittenberg
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:5 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109831
PMID
:23766941
Introduction:
Research and diagnosis in medicine and biology often require the assessment of a large amount of microscopy image data. Although on the one hand, digital pathology and new bioimaging technologies find their way into clinical practice and pharmaceutical research, some general methodological issues in automated image analysis are still open.
Methods:
In this study, we address the problem of fitting the parameters in a microscopy image segmentation pipeline. We propose to fit the parameters of the pipeline's modules with optimization algorithms, such as, genetic algorithms or coordinate descents, and show how visual exploration of the parameter space can help to identify sub-optimal parameter settings that need to be avoided.
Results:
This is of significant help in the design of our automatic parameter fitting framework, which enables us to tune the pipeline for large sets of micrographs.
Conclusion:
The underlying parameter spaces pose a challenge for manual as well as automated parameter optimization, as the parameter spaces can show several local performance maxima. Hence, optimization strategies that are not able to jump out of local performance maxima, like the hill climbing algorithm, often result in a local maximum.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (3) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
A statistical framework for analyzing hypothesized interactions between cells imaged using multispectral microscopy and multiple immunohistochemical markers
Chris J Rose, Khimara Naidoo, Vanessa Clay, Kim Linton, John A Radford, Richard J Byers
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:4 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109856
PMID
:23766940
Background:
Multispectral microscopy and multiple staining can be used to identify cells with distinct immunohistochemical (IHC) characteristics. We present here a method called hypothesized interaction distribution (HID) analysis for characterizing the statistical distribution of pair-wise spatial relationships between cells with particular IHC characteristics and apply it to clinical data.
Materials and Methods:
We retrospectively analyzed data from a study of 26 follicular lymphoma patients in which sections were stained for CD20 and YY1. HID analysis, using leave-one-out validation, was used to assign patients to one of two groups. We tested the null hypothesis of no difference in Kaplan-Meier survival curves between the groups.
Results:
Shannon entropy of HIDs assigned patients to groups that had significantly different survival curves (median survival was 7.70 versus 110 months,
P
= 0.00750). Hypothesized interactions between pairs of cells positive for both CD20 and YY1 were associated with poor survival.
Conclusions:
HID analysis provides quantitative inferences about possible interactions between spatially proximal cells with particular IHC characteristics. In follicular lymphoma, HID analysis was able to distinguish between patients with poor versus good survival, and it may have diagnostic and prognostic utility in this and other diseases.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (4) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
Automated segmentation of atherosclerotic histology based on pattern classification
Arna van Engelen, Wiro J Niessen, Stefan Klein, Harald C Groen, Kim van Gaalen, Hence J Verhagen, Jolanda J Wentzel, Aad van der Lugt, Marleen de Bruijne
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:3 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109844
PMID
:23766939
Background:
Histology sections provide accurate information on atherosclerotic plaque composition, and are used in various applications. To our knowledge, no automated systems for plaque component segmentation in histology sections currently exist.
Materials and Methods:
We perform pixel-wise classification of fibrous, lipid, and necrotic tissue in Elastica Von Gieson-stained histology sections, using features based on color channel intensity and local image texture and structure. We compare an approach where we train on independent data to an approach where we train on one or two sections per specimen in order to segment the remaining sections. We evaluate the results on segmentation accuracy in histology, and we use the obtained histology segmentations to train plaque component classification methods in
ex vivo
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and
in vivo
MRI and computed tomography (CT).
Results:
In leave-one-specimen-out experiments on 176 histology slices of 13 plaques, a pixel-wise accuracy of 75.7 ± 6.8% was obtained. This increased to 77.6 ± 6.5% when two manually annotated slices of the specimen to be segmented were used for training. Rank correlations of relative component volumes with manually annotated volumes were high in this situation (
P
= 0.82-0.98). Using the obtained histology segmentations to train plaque component classification methods in
ex vivo
MRI and
in vivo
MRI and CT resulted in similar image segmentations for training on the automated histology segmentations as for training on a fully manual ground truth. The size of the lipid-rich necrotic core was significantly smaller when training on fully automated histology segmentations than when manually annotated histology sections were used. This difference was reduced and not statistically significant when one or two slices per section were manually annotated for histology segmentation.
Conclusions:
Good histology segmentations can be obtained by automated segmentation, which show good correlations with ground truth volumes. In addition, these can be used to develop segmentation methods in other imaging modalities. Accuracy increases when one or two sections of the same specimen are used for training, which requires a limited amount of user interaction in practice.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (2) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
TMARKER: A free software toolkit for histopathological cell counting and staining estimation
Peter J Schüffler, Thomas J Fuchs, Cheng Soon Ong, Peter J Wild, Niels J Rupp, Joachim M Buhmann
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:2 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109804
PMID
:23766938
Background:
Histological tissue analysis often involves manual cell counting and staining estimation of cancerous cells. These assessments are extremely time consuming, highly subjective and prone to error, since immunohistochemically stained cancer tissues usually show high variability in cell sizes, morphological structures and staining quality. To facilitate reproducible analysis in clinical practice as well as for cancer research, objective computer assisted staining estimation is highly desirable.
Methods:
We employ machine learning algorithms as randomized decision trees and support vector machines for nucleus detection and classification. Superpixels as segmentation over the tissue image are classified into foreground and background and thereafter into malignant and benign, learning from the user's feedback. As a fast alternative without nucleus classification, the existing color deconvolution method is incorporated.
Results:
Our program TMARKER connects already available workflows for computational pathology and immunohistochemical tissue rating with modern active learning algorithms from machine learning and computer vision. On a test dataset of human renal clear cell carcinoma and prostate carcinoma, the performance of the used algorithms is equivalent to two independent pathologists for nucleus detection and classification.
Conclusion:
We present a novel, free and operating system independent software package for computational cell counting and staining estimation, supporting IHC stained tissue analysis in clinic and for research. Proprietary toolboxes for similar tasks are expensive, bound to specific commercial hardware (e.g. a microscope) and mostly not quantitatively validated in terms of performance and reproducibility. We are confident that the presented software package will proof valuable for the scientific community and we anticipate a broader application domain due to the possibility to interactively learn models for new image types.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (22) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Symposium - Original Research:
HyMaP: A hybrid magnitude-phase approach to unsupervised segmentation of tumor areas in breast cancer histology images
Adnan M Khan, Hesham El-Daly, Emma Simmons, Nasir M Rajpoot
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:1 (30 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.109802
PMID
:23766931
Background:
Segmentation of areas containing tumor cells in standard H&E histopathology images of breast (and several other tissues) is a key task for computer-assisted assessment and grading of histopathology slides. Good segmentation of tumor regions is also vital for automated scoring of immunohistochemical stained slides to restrict the scoring or analysis to areas containing tumor cells only and avoid potentially misleading results from analysis of stromal regions. Furthermore, detection of mitotic cells is critical for calculating key measures such as mitotic index; a key criteria for grading several types of cancers including breast cancer. We show that tumor segmentation can allow detection and quantification of mitotic cells from the standard H&E slides with a high degree of accuracy without need for special stains, in turn making the whole process more cost-effective.
Method:
Based on the tissue morphology, breast histology image contents can be divided into four regions: Tumor, Hypocellular Stroma (HypoCS), Hypercellular Stroma (HyperCS), and tissue fat (Background). Background is removed during the preprocessing stage on the basis of color thresholding, while HypoCS and HyperCS regions are segmented by calculating features using magnitude and phase spectra in the frequency domain, respectively, and performing unsupervised segmentation on these features.
Results:
All images in the database were hand segmented by two expert pathologists. The algorithms considered here are evaluated on three pixel-wise accuracy measures: precision, recall, and F1-Score. The segmentation results obtained by combining HypoCS and HyperCS yield high F1-Score of 0.86 and 0.89 with respect to the ground truth.
Conclusions:
In this paper, we show that segmentation of breast histopathology image into hypocellular stroma and hypercellular stroma can be achieved using magnitude and phase spectra in the frequency domain. The segmentation leads to demarcation of tumor margins leading to improved accuracy of mitotic cell detection.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (9) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Research Article:
A high-performance spatial database based approach for pathology imaging algorithm evaluation
Fusheng Wang, Jun Kong, Jingjing Gao, Lee A.D. Cooper, Tahsin Kurc, Zhengwen Zhou, David Adler, Cristobal Vergara-Niedermayr, Bryan Katigbak, Daniel J Brat, Joel H Saltz
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:5 (14 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.108543
PMID
:23599905
Background:
Algorithm evaluation provides a means to characterize variability across image analysis algorithms, validate algorithms by comparison with human annotations, combine results from multiple algorithms for performance improvement, and facilitate algorithm sensitivity studies. The sizes of images and image analysis results in pathology image analysis pose significant challenges in algorithm evaluation. We present an efficient parallel spatial database approach to model, normalize, manage, and query large volumes of analytical image result data. This provides an efficient platform for algorithm evaluation. Our experiments with a set of brain tumor images demonstrate the application, scalability, and effectiveness of the platform.
Context:
The paper describes an approach and platform for evaluation of pathology image analysis algorithms. The platform facilitates algorithm evaluation through a high-performance database built on the Pathology Analytic Imaging Standards (PAIS) data model.
Aims:
(1) Develop a framework to support algorithm evaluation by modeling and managing analytical results and human annotations from pathology images; (2) Create a robust data normalization tool for converting, validating, and fixing spatial data from algorithm or human annotations; (3) Develop a set of queries to support data sampling and result comparisons; (4) Achieve high performance computation capacity via a parallel data management infrastructure, parallel data loading and spatial indexing optimizations in this infrastructure.
Materials
and
Methods:
We have considered two scenarios for algorithm evaluation: (1) algorithm comparison where multiple result sets from different methods are compared and consolidated; and (2) algorithm validation where algorithm results are compared with human annotations. We have developed a spatial normalization toolkit to validate and normalize spatial boundaries produced by image analysis algorithms or human annotations. The validated data were formatted based on the PAIS data model and loaded into a spatial database. To support efficient data loading, we have implemented a parallel data loading tool that takes advantage of multi-core CPUs to accelerate data injection. The spatial database manages both geometric shapes and image features or classifications, and enables spatial sampling, result comparison, and result aggregation through expressive structured query language (SQL) queries with spatial extensions. To provide scalable and efficient query support, we have employed a shared nothing parallel database architecture, which distributes data homogenously across multiple database partitions to take advantage of parallel computation power and implements spatial indexing to achieve high I/O throughput.
Results:
Our work proposes a high performance, parallel spatial database platform for algorithm validation and comparison. This platform was evaluated by storing, managing, and comparing analysis results from a set of brain tumor whole slide images. The tools we develop are open source and available to download.
Conclusions:
Pathology image algorithm validation and comparison are essential to iterative algorithm development and refinement. One critical component is the support for queries involving spatial predicates and comparisons. In our work, we develop an efficient data model and parallel database approach to model, normalize, manage and query large volumes of analytical image result data. Our experiments demonstrate that the data partitioning strategy and the grid-based indexing result in good data distribution across database nodes and reduce I/O overhead in spatial join queries through parallel retrieval of relevant data and quick subsetting of datasets. The set of tools in the framework provide a full pipeline to normalize, load, manage and query analytical results for algorithm evaluation.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (6) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Review Article:
Privacy and security of patient data in the pathology laboratory
Ioan C Cucoranu, Anil V Parwani, Andrew J West, Gonzalo Romero-Lauro, Kevin Nauman, Alexis B Carter, Ulysses J Balis, Mark J Tuthill, Liron Pantanowitz
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:4 (14 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.108542
PMID
:23599904
Data protection and security are critical components of routine pathology practice because laboratories are legally required to securely store and transmit electronic patient data. With increasing connectivity of information systems, laboratory work-stations, and instruments themselves to the Internet, the demand to continuously protect and secure laboratory information can become a daunting task. This review addresses informatics security issues in the pathology laboratory related to passwords, biometric devices, data encryption, internet security, virtual private networks, firewalls, anti-viral software, and emergency security situations, as well as the potential impact that newer technologies such as mobile devices have on the privacy and security of electronic protected health information (ePHI). In the United States, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) govern the privacy and protection of medical information and health records. The HIPAA security standards final rule mandate administrative, physical, and technical safeguards to ensure the confidentiality, integrity, and security of ePHI. Importantly, security failures often lead to privacy breaches, invoking the HIPAA privacy rule as well. Therefore, this review also highlights key aspects of HIPAA and its impact on the pathology laboratory in the United States.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (7) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Research Article:
Digital pathology: Attitudes and practices in the Canadian pathology community
Magdaleni Bellis, Shereen Metias, Christopher Naugler, Aaron Pollett, Serge Jothy, George M Yousef
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:3 (14 March 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.108540
PMID
:23599903
Digital pathology is a rapidly evolving niche in the world of pathology and is likely to increase in popularity as technology improves. We performed a questionnaire for pathologists and pathology residents across Canada, in order to determine their current experiences and attitudes towards digital pathology; which modalities digital pathology is best suited for; and to assess the need for training in digital pathology amongst pathology residents and staff. An online survey consisting of 24 yes/no, multiple choice and free text questions regarding digital pathology was sent out via E-mail to all members of the Canadian Association of Pathologists and pathology residents across Canada. Survey results showed that telepathology (TP) is used in approximately 43% of institutions, primarily for teaching purposes (65%), followed by operating room consults (46%). Seventy-one percent of respondents believe there is a need for TP in their practice; 85% use digital images in their practice. The top two favored applications for digital pathology are teaching and consultation services, with the main advantage being easier access to cases. The main limitations of using digital pathology are cost and image/diagnostic quality. Sixty-two percent of respondents would attend training courses in pathology informatics and 91% think informatics should be part of residency training. The results of the survey indicate that Pathologists and residents across Canada do see a need for TP and the use of digital images in their daily practice. Integration of an informatics component into resident training programs and courses for staff Pathologists would be welcomed.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (12) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Original Article:
Application of whole slide image markup and annotation for pathologist knowledge capture
Walter S Campbell, Kirk W Foster, Steven H Hinrichs
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:2 (28 February 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.107953
PMID
:23599902
Objective:
The ability to transfer image markup and annotation data from one scanned image of a slide to a newly acquired image of the same slide within a single vendor platform was investigated. The goal was to study the ability to use image markup and annotation data files as a mechanism to capture and retain pathologist knowledge without retaining the entire whole slide image (WSI) file.
Methods:
Accepted mathematical principles were investigated as a method to overcome variations in scans of the same glass slide and to accurately associate image markup and annotation data across different WSI of the same glass slide. Trilateration was used to link fixed points within the image and slide to the placement of markups and annotations of the image in a metadata file.
Results:
Variation in markup and annotation placement between WSI of the same glass slide was reduced from over 80 μ to less than 4 μ in the x-axis and from 17 μ to 6 μ in the y-axis (
P
< 0.025).
Conclusion:
This methodology allows for the creation of a highly reproducible image library of histopathology images and interpretations for educational and research use.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (1) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Technical note:
The successful implementation of a licensed data management interface between a Sunquest
®
laboratory information system and an AB SCIEX
TM
mass spectrometer
Deborah French, Enrique Terrazas
J Pathol Inform
2013, 4:1 (31 January 2013)
DOI
:10.4103/2153-3539.106682
PMID
:23599901
Background:
Interfacing complex laboratory equipment to laboratory information systems (LIS) has become a more commonly encountered problem in clinical laboratories, especially for instruments that do not have an interface provided by the vendor. Liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry is a great example of such complex equipment, and has become a frequent addition to clinical laboratories. As the testing volume on such instruments can be significant, manual data entry will also be considerable and the potential for concomitant transcription errors arises. Due to this potential issue, our aim was to interface an AB SCIEX
TM
mass spectrometer to our Sunquest
®
LIS.
Materials
and
Methods:
We licensed software for the data management interface from the University of Pittsburgh, but extended this work as follows: The interface was designed so that it would accept a text file exported from the AB SCIEX
TM
× 5500 QTrap
®
mass spectrometer, pre-process the file (using newly written code) into the correct format and upload it into Sunquest
®
via file transfer protocol.
Results:
The licensed software handled the majority of the interface tasks with the exception of converting the output from the Analyst
®
software to the required Sunquest
®
import format. This required writing of a "pre-processor" by one of the authors which was easily integrated with the supplied software.
Conclusions:
We successfully implemented the data management interface licensed from the University of Pittsburgh. Given the coding that was required to write the pre-processor, and alterations to the source code that were performed when debugging the software, we would suggest that before a laboratory decides to implement such an interface, it would be necessary to have a competent computer programmer available.
[ABSTRACT]
[HTML Full text]
[PDF]
[Mobile Full text]
[EPub]
[Citations (3) ]
[PubMed]
[Sword Plugin for Repository]
Beta
Sitemap
|
What's New
Feedback
|
Copyright and Disclaimer
|
Privacy Notice
© Journal of Pathology Informatics | Published by Wolters Kluwer -
Medknow
Online since 10
th
March, 2010